I'm a FBA seller and I'm currently stuck in a reimbursement nightmare that I believe many of you have experienced in one form or another. I'm posting this to raise awareness and hopefully get some advice — or at least find out I'm not alone.
Here's the situation:
We have removal orders set up to return unsellable FBA inventory to our own 3PL warehouse. The first time we received a wrong removal order, I contacted Seller Support and provided a product photo + a tracking label photo. The agent was incredibly helpful — they located the Shipment ID and ASIN, and I got reimbursed smoothly.
Removal Order ID: Gau6XMMRCm
Amazon Case ID: 20410675881
Then things got… interesting.
I then mentioned to the agent that we received another batch of 8 incorrect units from another removal order (oGUK8Bxh1h).
I provide the tracking label and pallet-level photo of everything received
The same agent asks for: Unboxed product photos and LPN stickers
I provided one set of photos — one unboxed product + its LPN — because all 8 units came in identical outer boxes, and I assumed one example would be sufficient to prove that the items we received were not what we were supposed to get.
Then the case people replied, saying they need documentation for EVERY SINGLE UNIT. Photos of all 6 sides of each product and each outer box.
I was shocked. I went back to chat support (since they seemed more responsive). I shared what I already had:
*1 unboxed product photo
*1 LPN photo
*1 tracking label photo
*1 pallet-level photo
The agent immediately said: "Great, we can reimburse you for one unit."
I said: "But the removal order has 8 units. All 8 are wrong."
He then repeated the same requirement after checking the case — photos of all 6 sides of each product and each outer box.
Here's where it gets even more frustrating:
Every time I ask my 3PL warehouse to take new photos, I incur labor charges. The products are sitting in my warehouse, racking up storage fees every single day. At this point, the cumulative cost of:
*Warehouse photo-taking fees
*Storage fees for these wrong items
*My own time chasing this
…is starting to approach — if not exceed — whatever Amazon might eventually reimburse me for these 8 units.
So I proposed a solution: let me ship these 8 units back to Amazon so they can investigate in person. That would be a 3-win situation:
*Amazon gets the physical evidence they need, recover their mistake
*I stop paying storage fees
*The rightful owner (if any) gets their inventory back (the items seem very nice)
(Not mentioned I have already been charged the return fee to have these wrong items show in my warehouse at the first place)
But they refused.
I even asked if the video would work, not they refused.
I kept pushing on the photo front. Eventually, the agent told me to provide:
*Product images outside the box/packaging
*Packaging slip or tracking label image
*LPN sticker image
I had my warehouse take new photos of every single unit — product photos, LPN photos, and the tracking label.
And now? Amazon is back with the 6 sides requirement and just keeps responding with the same words and ignore to support me further. (not to mention some wrong items I receive are cooking pots, 6 sides, really?)
My honest feeling:
The goalposts keep moving. The requirements keep escalating. And it feels like the larger the claim amount becomes, the stricter the requirements get. It's almost as if Amazon is making the process so burdensome that sellers just give up and walk away.
I'm currently waiting for their next response (case ID: 20914159331). I have received zero reimbursement for these 8 units so far. I'm paying daily storage fees for products I don't even sell. I've already paid for photos that should have been more than enough to prove we received the wrong items.
Has anyone else experienced this kind of ever-changing photo requirement for removal order claims?
Has anyone successfully escalated this type of issue and gotten a fair resolution?
I've seen other sellers post similar frustrations. This seems to be a pattern, not an exception.
I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for consistency and fairness.